Best Pizza Restaurants in New York, United States

14 pizza restaurants ranked by Addagio Score. Average rating: 4.7/5. Prices from NZ$3 to NZ$65.

Last updated: August 2026

14

Total

75/100

Avg Score

4.7 ★

Avg Rating

0

Verified

Top Ranked

182
Belgian Chocolate Covered Strawberries$3Handmade Classic X-Large Oatmeal Raisin Cookies$8Fresh Handmade Strawberry Filled Croissant$8+7 more
282
Advance Orders for Local Pick Up$19Cupcake Decorating Workshop$19Catering$19+1 more
381
Cupping SessionNZ$25Barista ClassNZ$65

Rating Distribution

5
13 (93%)
4
1 (7%)
3
0 (0%)
2
0 (0%)
1
0 (0%)

Price Range (NZD)

22
NZD 3-15
35
NZD 15-28
9
NZD 28-40
6
NZD 53-65

From NZ$3 to NZ$65 · Avg NZ$21

Key Facts

  • Total pizza restaurants: 14
  • Verified profiles: 0 (0%)
  • With photos: 11
  • Unique services: 20
  • Price range: NZ$3NZ$65
  • Average Addagio Score: 75/100

How We Rank

The Addagio Score (0-100) is a composite quality metric based on multiple factors:

Customer Rating40%
Review Volume20%
Profile Completeness15%
Photos Available10%
Verified Status10%
Price Transparency5%

Are you a business owner in New York?

Get found by customers searching for services in New York. Manage bookings, automate scheduling, and grow your online presence — all in one platform.

Join 10,000+ businesses already listed on Addagio