Best Italian Restaurants in Tampa, Florida

Compare 14 top-rated italian restaurants in Tampa, Florida. Read reviews, check prices, and book directly online.

14 results

W
1

Westwood Cafe / Kebabs & Co.

5.0(56)

2002 N Lois Ave Ste 140, Tampa, FL 33607, USA

Westwood Cafe / Kebabs & Co. is a cozy cafe located inside an office building in Tampa, offering a clean, welcoming atmosphere with quick service and budget-friendly prices. It specializes in Mediterranean food, including standout doner kebabs and fries, along with a variety of wraps, burgers, and healthy options.

Cheese CalzoneSpecialty Slice (Multiple Toppings)Gluten-Free Pizza (10")
L'Amorino Italian Restaurant2

L'Amorino Italian Restaurant

4.9(65)

6102 S MacDill Ave Ste a, Tampa, FL 33611, USA

L'Amorino Italian Restaurant in Tampa offers an unforgettable dining experience with authentic Italian flavors crafted from fresh, high-quality ingredients. It is a perfect destination for locals and visitors alike, bringing a true taste of Italy to South Tampa.

Dine-inTakeoutDelivery
Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar3

Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar

4.7(3777)

1724 E 7th Ave, Tampa, FL 33605, USA

Due Amici Pizza & Pasta Bar is a family-run restaurant located in Ybor City, Tampa, Florida. They specialize in handcrafted sauces, in-house made pizza dough, and fresh ingredients for their pizzas and pastas. The restaurant offers dine-in, pickup, delivery, and catering services.

Dine-InPickupDelivery
Osteria Natalina4

Osteria Natalina

4.7(762)

3215 S MacDill Ave, Tampa, FL 33629, USA

Osteria Natalina is a family-owned, authentic Italian restaurant located in the heart of South Tampa, Florida, established in 2000. It offers a cozy and intimate dining experience, serving traditional dishes based on Mama Natalina's secret recipes from Rimini, Italy, with a specialty in seafood.

Chill Bros Scoop Shop5

Chill Bros Scoop Shop

4.7(643)

1910 E 7th Ave Ste 101, Tampa, FL 33605, USA

Chill Bros Scoop Shop is Tampa Bay's beloved destination for handcrafted, small-batch ice cream, made with passion right in their hometown. Drawing inspiration from old-world Italian gelato techniques combined with their local Tampa upbringing, Chill Bros. creates truly next-level frozen treats. They start with a simple, all-natural 5-ingredient base, and elevate it by sourcing the finest local ingredients. Every mix-in, sauce, and baked good is meticulously hand-crafted in their SoHo kitchen, ensuring unparalleled freshness and quality in every scoop. With five vibrant scoop shops across Tampa, including locations in Ybor City, Bay to Bay, Armature Works, South Howard, and Water Street, a delicious escape is always nearby. Whether you're exploring the historic streets of Ybor or enjoying the waterfront at Armature Works, you can find your favorite handcrafted scoops, pints, and sundaes. For ultimate convenience, Chill Bros. offers online ordering with local delivery, bringing their ice cream bliss directly to your door. They also feature a rotating selection of nostalgic and innovative flavors, like the 'All-American Summer Series' with Bonfire S'mores, Black Cherry Stracciatella, and Rocket Pop Sorbetto, alongside year-round favorites like Key Lime Pie and Guava Pastelito. Vegan options are also available. Chill Bros. is more than just an ice cream shop; it's a taste of Tampa Bay, made with love and expertise.

Ice Cream ScoopsIce Cream PintsSundaes
Bella Roma NY Pizza6

Bella Roma NY Pizza

4.7(311)

500 S Howard Ave Ste f, Tampa, FL 33606, USA

Italian restaurant in Tampa. 311+ reviews on Google. Book directly and save.

Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza7

Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza

4.6(7975)

203 E Twiggs St, Tampa, FL 33602, USA

For over two decades, Eddie & Sam's N.Y. Pizza has brought the authentic taste of New York pizza to downtown Tampa, known for its wide, foldable slices and thin, crispy crust made with authentic New York water. They offer a variety of pizzas, appetizers, wings, salads, pasta, heroes, and desserts, available for dine-in, pickup or delivery.

14" Cheese Pizza$1420" Cheese Pizza$2428" Cheese Pizza$40
OLIVIA8

OLIVIA

4.6(2905)

3601 W Swann Ave, Tampa, FL 33609, USA

Italian restaurant in Tampa. 2905+ reviews on Google. Book directly and save.

Luigi's Kitchen9

Luigi's Kitchen

4.6(883)

3671 S Westshore Blvd, Tampa, FL 33629, USA

Italian restaurant in Tampa. 883+ reviews on Google. Book directly and save.

The Brother Trattoria10

The Brother Trattoria

4.6(341)

2402 S MacDill Ave, Tampa, FL 33629, USA

The Brother Trattoria is a family-owned Italian restaurant in South Tampa, Florida, offering authentic Italian cuisine with a creative flair. They provide a full menu including appetizers, salads, pastas, entrees, and wood-fired pizzas, along with inventive seasonal cocktails. The restaurant also specializes in catering for various events and hosting private parties.

Catering ServicesEvent HostingOnline Reservations
Malio's11

Malio's

4.5(1490)

400 N Ashley Dr, Tampa, FL 33602, USA

Malio's Prime Steakhouse is a family-owned fine dining restaurant in downtown Tampa, known for its high-quality steaks, fresh seafood, extensive wine list, and exceptional service. It offers a memorable dining experience with views of the Hillsborough River and the University of Tampa, and also features a cigar-friendly patio and private dining options.

6oz Prime Petit Filet$598oz Prime Main Filet$6916oz Prime New York Strip$72
Santoro's Pizzeria12

Santoro's Pizzeria

4.5(1478)

1329 W Cass St, Tampa, FL 33606, USA

Santoro's Pizzeria is a popular New Jersey-style slice shop located in Tampa, Florida, known for its crispy, thin-crust pizzas and welcoming atmosphere. It offers a variety of traditional and specialty pies, along with other Italian-American comfort food.

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria13

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria

4.4(1526)

514 N Franklin St STE 101, Tampa, FL 33602, USA

Bavaro's Pizza Napoletana & Pastaria in Tampa, Florida, is known for being the first traditional Neapolitan Pizzeria in the state, opened in March 2009. They are committed to authentic Italian cuisine, using a hand-crafted, wood-fired brick oven and top-of-the-line ingredients sourced directly from Italy. The restaurant offers gourmet pizza, homemade pasta, antipasti, and classic desserts, aiming

Dine-inTakeoutDelivery
Caffeine Roasters14

Caffeine Roasters

4.4(746)

2420 W Kennedy Blvd, Tampa, FL 33609, USA

Caffeine Roasters is a Tampa-based coffee roaster established in 2016, known for its authentic craftsmanship, small-batch coffee, and cozy atmosphere. They offer a full range of specialty coffee beverages, house-made breakfast, lunch, and pastries, and operate multiple locations including a roastery with a drive-thru.

Italian Blend, Medium Dark Roast Coffee Beans$16Honduras, Medium Roast Coffee Beans$16Uganda, Medium Roast Coffee Beans$16

Frequently Asked Questions

How many italian restaurants are in Tampa?+

We found 14 italian restaurants in Tampa, Florida on Addagio. Browse their profiles, compare prices, and book directly online.

How do I book a italian restaurant in Tampa?+

Choose a italian restaurant from the list above, view their services and prices, then click "Book" to schedule your appointment. No account required.

Are these italian restaurants verified?+

All businesses on Addagio are sourced from Google Maps and verified with real data — addresses, phone numbers, and services are confirmed.

View detailed rankings with scores & charts → See Addagio Scores, price comparisons, service availability, and FAQ.

This page in other languages: